MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND TRAINING
THUONGMAI UNIVERSITY
-------------------------
CONSMER CREDIT DEVELOPMENT OF FINANCE
COMPANIES UNDER COMMERCIAL BANK IN
VIETNAM
Major: Commercial business
Code: 934.01.21
SUMMARY OF ECONOMIC DOTORAL THESIS
Ha Noi, 2020
The thesis was completed at Thuongmai University
Supervisors:
1. Supervisor 1: Prof.Doctor. Đinh Van Son
2. Supervisor 2: Deputy Prof.Doctor Le Thi Kim Nhung
Critical reviewer 1 : --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critical reviewer 2 : --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
----------------- -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Critical reviewer 3 : --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The thesis will be defended in front of the University-level Thesis Evaluation Council
at the Thuongmai University
At……….hour………date………month……….year……………
The thesis can be found at: National Library
Thuongmai University Libarary
LIST OF PUBLICATIONS PUBLISHED RELATED TO THE THESIS
1. To Thanh Huong 2020, Experience in developing consumer credit of some finance companies in the
world, Asia Pacific Economic Review, February 2020, pages 107-109.
2. To Thanh Huong, 2020, Current situation of consumer credit development of finance companies
under commercial banks in Vietnam, Journal of Economics and Forecasting, No. 08 March 2020,
pages 37-39.
3. Nguyen Thi Phuong Lien, To Thanh Huong, 2020, Development of consumer credit products of
finance companies under commercial banks in Vietnam, Proceedings of national science conferences,
Personal finance - Theory and practice in a new context, Science and Technology Publishing House.
4. Nguyen Thi Phuong Lien, To Thanh Huong, 2020, Development of consumer credit distribution
channels of finance companies under commercial banks in Vietnam, Proceedings of national science
conferences, Commercial Journal of Commercial Science, August 2020.
1
HEADING
1. THE URGENCY OF THE SUBJECT
Consumer credit for decades has been provided by two main actors in the financial market to
customers, including finance companies and commercial banks. Although both entities are providing credit, the
customer segment has a clear difference, in which commercial banks focus on providing credit for standard
customers who meet loan conditions of the bank, while the financial institutions mainly approach segments of
customers that are difficult to access loans from commercial banks, also known as subprime customers. Thanks
to the clear customer classification between finance companies and commercial banks, it has led to differences
in business activities of the two lenders and benefits for customers. In addition to the benefits of credit for
customers, lenders and the economy, excessive credit growth, lack of strategy and uncontrolled safety in the
legal framework can cause crises. Economic crisis on a national and global scale. The clear evidence is that the
global economic crisis of 2008-2009 originated from North America originated from rampant under-standard
credit development. This is also a lesson for emerging markets with a lot of room for developing credit and at
risk of hot credit growth, requiring strict control and safe and sustainable credit growth solutions.
Retail banking activities in Vietnam have been formed and developed strongly along with the
development of the commercial banking system. Standard consumer credits for individual customers have
been widely deployed by commercial banks, becoming a profitable activity for commercial banks in the
context of difficult credit growth from enterprises. With the structure of the golden population (69% of the
population is of working age), the average income and living standards are increasing, the consumption
behaviors of the people change in a positive direction, the credit market in Vietnam is growing. It has grown
rapidly in the past 10 years and is expected to continue to grow in the future, with an average growth rate of
about 20% per year until 2025. In fact, Vietnamese commercial banks are having many advantages when
participating in the consumer credit market segment and seeking new development opportunities to enhance
the competitiveness and position of the market.
Along with the policy of the Government and the State Bank on strengthening consumer credit
activities of domestic financel companies and restricting the license to open new finance companies in
Vietnam, many commercial banks are looking taking ownership of a finance companies to deploy credit
operations for subordinate customers is a fertile land to maximize the advantages of capital, network,
management experience etc and contribute to achieving strategic targets of commercial banks in the period of
2020-2025. Therefore, the period 2017-2019 witnessed a series of mergers between commercial banks and
finance companies, 02 finance companies under commercial banks including MCredit and HD Saison officially
came into operation. In 2017 and 2018, some commercial banks completed the procedures for acquiring
financel companies in 2018-2019, such as Southeast Asia Commercial Joint Stock Bank and Tien Phong
Commercial Joint Stock Bank. At the same time, many other commercial banks are also preparing to submit to
the State Bank on the acquisition of finance companies, showing the increasing competition pressure in the
consumer credit market.
In the first phase of credit activity implementation, a number of advantages help finance companies
under commercial banks compete with independent finance companies stemming from the support of the
parent commercial banks. However, the finance companies also face challenging challenges from: (i)
Pressure to transform the digital platform business model to the 4.0 trend; (ii) Competition is increasingly
fierce in the field of the financel companies with the accession of Fintech companies, especially the form of
loan through APP has flourished because many competitors from China and Indonesia have moved to
Vietnam after the collapse. disruption of the peer lending market; iii) The legal framework is increasingly
completed in the direction of strictly controlling the operations of the finance companies and restricting
unsecured cash loans according to the schedule; and (iv) Regulations on restricting credit growth of the State
Bank for many years.
Owned by leading domestic commercial banks in Vietnam, the finance companies are expected to
actively contribute to the policy of restricting black credit, contributing to lending transactions to people. the
integration of legal transactions, responsible lending activities with customers and the community, preserving
and strengthening the brand reputation of the commercial banks. The finance companies need to determine
which business model is appropriate, which solutions are needed to exist and develop properly, balancing
profit and safety goals, prestige in relation with the general strategy of the parent commercial banks, well
implementing the policy of restricting black credit, protecting the brand reputation of the parent commercial
2
banks and its finance companies through the responsible lending activities. Stemming from the above reality,
the author chooses "Development of consumer credit of finance companies under commercial banks in
Vietnam" as his thesis topic.
2. OBJECTIVES AND RESEARCH MISSION
* Objectives of the study
The objective of the thesis is to establish a theoretical framework to analyze and evaluate the current
situation of consumer credit development of the finance companies, thereby proposing scientific-based
solutions and practicality for developing consumer credit of the finance companies in Vietnam.
* Research mission
- In theory: the thesis clarifies the theory of consumer credit and consumer credit development in the
context of international economic integration and increases competition pressure. The thesis also focuses on
analyzing international experience on consumer credit from which to apply the practical conditions of the
financel companies in Vietnam.
- In practice: On the basis of analyzing and assessing the current situation of consumer credit
development of the financel companies in Vietnam in the period of 2014-2019, defining the limitation, the
cause of the limitations and shortcomings in consumer credit development, the research shows the opportunities
and challenges, thereby proposing orientations and solutions for developing consumer credit of the financel
companies til 2025 in accordance with the reality of international economic integration of Vietnam.
3. SUBJECTS AND SCOPE OF THE STUDY
* Research subjects
The object of the thesis research is the development of consumer credit of the finance companies in
Vietnam.
* Research scope
- Regarding the research content: The thesis studies the theoretical basis of consumer credit and
consumer credit development of the financel companies in Vietnam, assesses the current situation of the
financel companies in Vietnam, some solutions for developing the financel companies in Vietnam. Regarding
the content of the development, the thesis focuses on researching ways to develop consumer credit in quantity
(including: products, distribution channels, markets, sales promotion, interest rates), developing consumer
credit quality (including risk management model, credit policy and process), other issues studied under the
approach are factors affecting the finance companies's consumer credit development.
- Regarding the research space: the dissertation examines a typical case study of four out of six finance
companies belonging to commercial banks in Vietnam, including FE Credit, HD Saison, Mcredit and SHB
Finance.
- Regarding the study time: practical information and data on consumer credit development is
collected in the 2014-2019 period, the proposed solutions and recommendations apply for the period from
2020 to 2025.
4. RESEARCH QUESTIONS
(1) Characteristics and role of consumer credit of the finance companies? Content, evaluation criteria and
factors affecting the development of consumer credit of the finance companies?
(2) Can international experiences in consumer credit development be applied to consumer credit
development practices of the finance companies in Vietnam?
(3) What is the current situation of consumer credit development of the finance companies? What are the
successes, limitations and causes of limitations?
(4) In the era of Industry 4.0, how do the finance companies in Vietnam need to determine how to develop
consumer credit? Opportunities and challenges for the finance companies in Vietnam in the digital age?
(5) What solutions are needed for the finance companies in Vietnam to overcome challenges and develop
consumer credit in the right direction?
5. NEW CONTRIBUTIONS OF THE THESIS
(1) In theory: Analyzing and clarifying characteristics of consumer credit of the finance companies in
the relationship of interests with parent commercial banks in terms of business strategy, business model,
development methods compared to independent finance companies. Establishing a theoretical framework for
developing consumer credit on two perspectives: quality development method and credit quality