30<br />
<br />
NG6N NGC & B6I S6NG<br />
<br />
S 6 5 (247)-2016<br />
<br />
BAN THEM VE CAU BI D Q N G CO DANG N-V<br />
TRONG TffiNG VIET<br />
FURTHER DISCUSSIONS ABOUT THE PASSIVE VOICE IN THE FORM N-V<br />
IN VIETNAMESE LANGUAGE<br />
NGUYfiN MANH T I £ N<br />
(ThS-NCS; Dal hpc Sir ph^m, DH Thdi NguySn)<br />
Abstract: The article points out that in Vietnamese language because there is no clear<br />
opposition about the forms between the active verb and passive verb, there is no apparent formal<br />
opposition between the subject and the complement. To distinguish the subject from tiie<br />
complement in the passive voice style with the form N-V, it is necessary to consider each<br />
specific case; on the other hand, it is required to base on the realized meanmg of the verb predicate; also, we should rely on the certain formal methods.<br />
Key words: passive voice; active verb; passive verb; formal method.<br />
(3a) Nd ldm bdng bgc. (Nguyen Cong Hoan)<br />
(Din tiieo [5.158]).<br />
(4a) Chiia xdy ta thdi cdch day mgt nghin sdu<br />
trdm ndm bdi mdt nhd suAn Dg. (Chi Lan Vi6n).<br />
(Din tiieo [5,159]).<br />
(Sa) Bay gid, tiiu thuyit hdu hit viit bhng v&i<br />
xudi. (Nguyin Dinh Thi) (Ddn theo [5,159]).<br />
(6a) KM dong nude da chgn dung (ddt Igi rdo<br />
rdo doxuSng.) (Chu Vdn) (Ddn tiieo [6,107]).<br />
2. Trong vifc phdn tieh nhiing cdu hay c^u<br />
tnic ttdn ddy, cd hai logi y kien khdc nhau:<br />
a) Coi ^ y Id nhiing cdu hay ciu tide cd mt<br />
hlnh: CN - VN trong do "jtr ddo vf tri cua<br />
danh tu biiu thf ddi twpig len trudc d^ng tu la<br />
cd tdc dung biiu thfy nghid bf dgn^* [3,207].<br />
Theo quan nifm ndy, 'y nghTa bf dgng biiu thj<br />
ed bang cd m$t cdu true ca phdp nhu vgy<br />
Dudi ddy, sS dupe xem xdt Id mft kilu cdu<br />
khdng phdi Id dgng bf dgng cua riing dgng tu<br />
(ciu tnic) cy thi thufc trudng hpp trdn ddy.<br />
md lay nghta bf ddng eiia cd edu" [3,208].<br />
Kieu cdu ndy gom hai thanh t l chfnh: mft<br />
b) Coi day Id nhftng cdu hay ciu true khdng<br />
danh tft (cym danh tft) ve nghta bieu hay nghTa<br />
sdu chi dii thi hogt dfng (dupc ki hifu Id N) chu ngft vdi bo ngft dupc dao Idn trudc vj ng&.<br />
va mft dfng tft ngoai hudng (dupc ki hifu Id (Md hmh: BN - VN [5,154-159]).<br />
Theo cdch phdn tich b), sd di till tft (danh<br />
V).<br />
tft) dftng trudc dfng tft d nhftng cdu tren d^y<br />
D I tifn cho vifc thao lufn, xin din Igi mft<br />
dupc coi Id b l ngft ddo chft khdng dupc coi \i<br />
so vf dy dd dupc cdc tdc gid din ra:<br />
chft ngft Id vi chiing khdng ddp ling dupc ti6u<br />
(la) Cd hai m? con vdn diu nuoi ndng bai<br />
chi efta chft ngft (dupc xdc ^itii bdng thii ph^<br />
nhOng cua phi nghid. (Nguyen Hlng) (Dan theo<br />
nguydn nhdn hda [5,151]).<br />
[3.211]).<br />
3.L Theo chiing tdi, neu phdn tich theo cdch<br />
(2a) Luc mam cam bung lin, (tdi dgp thdc<br />
bgn toi dgy.) (Nguyin Cong Hoan) (Ddn tiieo [3, thft hai se g|ip nhftng dilm vudng mdc rit kh6<br />
lugn gidi mft cdch tiiod ddng. Cy till:<br />
207]).<br />
<br />
1. Trong mpt bdi viet dupc cong bo gan day<br />
[4], chiing tdi da xem xdt sy dii Ifp giiia chft<br />
ngii vd bo ngft dya vdo thufc tinh ket ttj efta<br />
dfng tft - vj ngft; qua do, chi ra tfnh phftc tgp<br />
ciia sy dii ldp giiia dpng tft npi hudng vd dfng<br />
tft ngogi hudng va keo theo dilu do la tfnh<br />
phftc tgp ciia sy doi Igp gifta chu ngft va bo<br />
ngft trong tiing Viet . D I efp den sy dii Ifp<br />
giiia chii ngft vd b l ngft, khdng the khdng de<br />
cgp den nhftng cdu hay ciu tnic vdi vf ngft Id<br />
dpng tft ngogi hudng nhung dupc diing ldm<br />
thdi trong y nghTa nf i hudng. Trong nhthig<br />
cdu hay cau true nhu vgy, vifc phan bift chu<br />
ngft vdi b l ngft ciing gdp nhiing khd khdn nhit<br />
dinh vl doi lap giiia chiing khong dupc bieu<br />
hifn rd rdng.<br />
<br />
s l 5 (247)-2016<br />
<br />
N G O N N G t r & DCn S 6 N G<br />
<br />
I) Neu coi ddy Id nhihig cdu hay ciu trdc<br />
khdng chii ngu vdi vi ngft Id ngogi dfng tft<br />
(dfng tii ngogi hudng) vd b l ngft dupc ddo Idn<br />
phia trudc till phdi thiia nhgn rdng chdng Id<br />
nhihig cdu hay ciu true khdng trpn vpn (khdng<br />
diy du) vdi chu ngft bj tinh lupc. Tuy nhidn,<br />
each li gidi ndy vip phdi nhiing trd nggi sau:<br />
a) Tren thye tl, nhftng cau hay ciu tnic tren<br />
ddy khdng tgo an tupng ro rf t ve sy tinh lupc<br />
(chii ngu) md nhin chung, vin dupc edm nhfn<br />
nhu nhftng cdu hay cau tnic trpn vpn vi dl hilu<br />
dung nghTa cua ehiing, hiu nhu khdng can dya<br />
vao ngft cdnh de xdc dinh, khdi phyc Igi cdc tft<br />
bi cho la lupc bd.<br />
b) Trong nhilu trudng hpp, rit khd xac djnh<br />
chinh xdc cdc tft ngft dugc coi Id chft ngft hi<br />
lupc bd dya vao ngft cdnh; ban niia, ngay cd<br />
khi doan dupc chft the thyc te efta hogt dfng<br />
neu d vi ngft, vifc khdi phyc Igi chft ngft (bj coi<br />
la lupc bd) cung khdng dl ddng vl dilu dd cd<br />
thi cho ta nhung cdu hay cau tnic khdng ty<br />
nhien, binh thudng.So sdnh:<br />
3a) No ldm bdng loai bgc. —»• 3b) Nd, ngudi ta<br />
(ho?) l^n bdng loai bgc. (?)<br />
2a) Lite mdm earn bung len, tdi dgp thdc bgn<br />
toi dgy. —> 2b) Luc mdm cam chu nhd (?) bung<br />
lin. tdi ddp thiec bgn tdi ddy. (?)<br />
Ngodi ra, trong tnrdng hpp chu thi thyc t l<br />
ciia hogt dfng ndu d vj ngft da dupc bilu thj<br />
trong cau bdi tft gift vai trd trgng ngft (d cdu 4a)<br />
till vifc khdi phyc Igi chii ngft Id dilu hodn todn<br />
khdng till thyc hifn dupc. Ching hgn, khdng<br />
thi ndi: (4b) Chita ngudi ta x w edch ddy<br />
Idiodng 1600 ndm bdi mdt nhd suAn Dd.<br />
2) Vifc coi nhiing eau hay ciu trdc tren ddy<br />
Id nhiing cau hay ciu tnic vdi bo ngft ddo cung<br />
cd nhiing dilm virdnp mdc khdc. Cy till:<br />
a) Nhu da b i l t bd ngft dao, nhin chung, deu<br />
c6 thi chuyln xuing vj tri von cd d sau dfng tft<br />
md khdng dan den sy thay doi ca bdn cau tnic<br />
va y nghTa von c6 ciia cdu. So sdnh:<br />
(7a) Ldng tdi dfch ehiim roi. (Nam Cao)-><br />
(7b) Dfch chiim long tdi rdi.<br />
(8a) Sdch ndy khdng nen dgc.->(8b) Khdng<br />
nin dgc sdch ndy.<br />
b) Trong nhihig cdu hay ciu tnic dang xem<br />
xdt trdn ddy, vifc chuyln cac tii dupe coi Id bo<br />
<br />
31<br />
<br />
ngft ddo xuIng sau dfng tft - vj ngft se dan din<br />
sy thay dii mgnh tinh chit cft phdp cua cau, cy<br />
thi, s5 biln nhftng cdu (hay ciu trdc) dupc edm<br />
nhdn nhu cdu (ciu trfte) trpn vpn thanh cdu (cau<br />
true) khdng trpn v^n. So sdnh:<br />
(2a) iiic mdm cam bteng len, tdi ddp thdc bgn<br />
tdi ddy. —* (2c) Lm: bung mdm cam len, tdi d^<br />
thuc bgn tdi ddy.<br />
(3a) No ldm bdng lodi bgc. ~>(3c) Ldm no<br />
bdng lodi bgc.<br />
(4a) CMia xdv ta thdi cdch d^ khoang mgt<br />
nghin sdu trdm ndm bdi mgt nhd su An B0. —*<br />
(4c) Xdy ehiia td thdi cdch ddy khoang mgt<br />
nghin sdu trdm ndm bdi mdt nhd suAn D0.<br />
Nhu ede vi dy cho thiy, vifc chuyln dii trgt<br />
ty tft dd tgo ra nhiing cau hay ciu tnic r5 rdng Id<br />
khdng trpn vpn. Han niia, sy thay doi trft ty tft<br />
nhu d cdu (2c) cdn dan din sy thay dii quan<br />
trpng cd ve nghia (d cdu ndy, hogt dfng bung<br />
len cd till hilu Id boat dfng cua "for"" chft<br />
khdng phai Id cua chft nhd, hay nhdn vgt ndo<br />
dd). 0 cdu (4c), sy thay dii trgt ty tft din din sy<br />
khdng phu hpp hay khdng rd rang cua moi quan<br />
hf ngft nghTa giiia dfng tft xay vd cym danh tft<br />
mgt nhd su An Dd (c6 till hilu chu ngft ciia<br />
dpng tft xdy (bj tinh lupc) chi mpt ngudi khdc<br />
chft khdng phdi chfnh la mgt nhd su^<br />
Bg).<br />
3.2. Tren ca sd sy phdn tich tren, trong bdi<br />
vilt ndv, chiing tdi ngjiidng vl cdch phdn tfnh<br />
thft nhat; theo dd, nhiing cdu hay ciu true tren<br />
day dupc coi la nhiing cdu hay ciu true cd md<br />
hinh CN - VN. Tuy nhidn, khac vdi quan nifm<br />
dd dl cgp d cdch phdn tich thft nhit, chiing tdi<br />
cho ring y nghTa bj dfng d ddy, ve thyc chit,<br />
van gdn vdi i? nghTa ciia dpng tft - vi ngft. Ngodi<br />
ra, can phan bift kilu cdu bj dfng cd dgng N -V<br />
nhu trdn ddy vdi nhftng cau ciing cd dgng N - V<br />
trong dd cd sy tinh lupc chii ngft vd b l ngft<br />
dupc ddo Idn trudc vj ngft. Dudi ddy chiing tdi<br />
sd xin lugn gidi ldm rd van dl ndy.<br />
Ndt (Mng chft j' ttong nhiing cdu trdn day Id<br />
vl nghTa, chftng khdng midu td hdnh dfng ciia<br />
chft till hudng vdo doi thi md chii yiu bilu thj<br />
trgng thai bf dfng cda sy vft do cac danh tft<br />
ddng trude dpng tft bilu thj. Ndi cdch khdc,<br />
nhftng cau hay ciu true kieu trdn ddy thyc chit<br />
la cdu hay cau tnic bj dfng ttong dd cdc tft bj<br />
<br />
30<br />
<br />
N G 6 N N G C & Btn<br />
<br />
S6NG<br />
<br />
s l S (247)-2016<br />
<br />
BAN THEM VE CAU BI D Q N G CO DANG N-V<br />
TRONG TIENG VIET<br />
FURTHER DISCUSSIONS ABOUT THE PASSIVE VOICE IN THE FORM N-V<br />
IN VIETNAMESE LANGUAGE<br />
NGUY£N MANH TI£N<br />
(ThS-NCS; D^i hpc Sv ph^m, DH T h i i Nguydn)<br />
Abstract: The article points out that in Vietnamese language because there is no clear<br />
opposition about the forms between the active verb and passive verb, there is no apparent framal<br />
opposition between the subject and the complement. To distinguish the subject finm tiie<br />
complement in the passive voice style with the form N-V, it is necessary to consider each<br />
specific ease; on the other hand, it is required to base on the realized meaning of the verb predicate; also, we should rely on the certain formal methods.<br />
Key words: passive voice; active verb; passive verb; formal method.<br />
1. Trong mft bai viet dupc cdng b l gan ddy<br />
[4], chiing tdi dd xem xdt sy dii Ifp gifta chft<br />
ngft vd bo ngft dya vao thudc tfnh kit hi ciia<br />
ddng tft - vi ngft; qua dd, chi ra tfnh phftc tgp<br />
ciia sy doi lap gifta dpng tft ndi hudng vd dfng<br />
tft ngogi hudng va keo theo dilu do Id tfnh<br />
phftc tgp ciia sy dii Ifp gifta chu ngft vd b l<br />
ngft trong tieng Vift . Dl cap din sy dii Ifp<br />
gifta chft ngft vd bo ngft, khdng till khdng dd<br />
cap den nhiing cdu hay ciu tnic vdi vi ngft la<br />
dfng tft ngogi hudng nhung dupc diing ldm<br />
thdi trong y nghTa npi hudng. Trong nhiing<br />
cau hay ciu tnic nhu vfy, vifc phan bift chft<br />
ngft vdi b l ngft cung gfp nhftng khd khdn nhit<br />
djnh vl dii ldp gifta chiing khdng dupc bilu<br />
hifn r5 rdng.<br />
Dudi day, sd dupc xem xet Id mft kilu cdu<br />
(cau tnic) cy till thufc trudng hpp trdn day.<br />
Kieu cdu ndy gIm hai thanh to chinh: mft<br />
danh tft (cym danh tft) vl nghia bilu hay nghTa<br />
sdu chi dii till hogt dfng (dupc kf hifu Id N)<br />
va mft ddng tft ngoai hudng (dupc kf hifu la<br />
V).<br />
D I tifn cho vifc thdo lugn, xin dan Igi mft<br />
so vi dy dd dupc cdc tac gid din ra:<br />
(la) Cd hai m? con vdn diu nudi ndng bdi<br />
nhung cua phi nghia. (Nguyen Hlng) (Dan theo<br />
[3,211]).<br />
(2a) LUc mdm cam bung lin, (tdi d$p thuc<br />
bgn tdi dgy.) (Nguyin Cdng Hoan) (Din theo [3,<br />
207]).<br />
<br />
(3a) Nd ldm bdng bgc. (Nguyen Cdng Hoan)<br />
(Dantfieo[5, 158]).<br />
(4a) Chiia xdy tu tlidi cdch ddy mgt nghin sdu<br />
trdm ndm bai mdt nhd suAn D0. (Che Lan Vidn).<br />
(Dan tiieo [5,159]).<br />
(5a) B^ gid. tiiu thuyit hdu hit viit bdng vdn<br />
xudi. (Nguyin Dinh Thi) (Dan tfieo [5,159]).<br />
(6a) Khi ddng nude dd chdn dung (ddt Igi rdo<br />
rdo do xudng.) (Chu V5n) (Dan tiieo [6,107]).<br />
2. Trong vifc phdn tich nhiing cau hay ciu<br />
triic tren ddy, cd hai logi •^ kiln khde nhau:<br />
a) Coi ddy Id nhftng cdu hay ciu true cd mS<br />
hinh: CN - VN trong dd "sif ddo vf tri cOa<br />
danh td biiu thj ddi tugng lin trudc dgng ta Ui<br />
cd tdc dftng biiu thf^ nghid bi dgn^' [3,207].<br />
Theo quan nifm ndy, 'y nghTa bf dgng biiu thf<br />
ed bdng cd mgt cdu trae cii phdp nhu v^<br />
khong pkii Id dgng bf dgng eua rieng dgng t^<br />
md lay nghia bj ddng cua cd edi^' [3,208].<br />
b) Coi ddy la nhiing cdu hay ciu triic khdng<br />
chft ngft vdi b l ngft dupc ddo Idn trudc vi ng3.<br />
(Md hinh: BN - VN [5.154-159]).<br />
Theo cdch phdn tfch b), sd dT till td (danh<br />
tft) dftng trudc dfng tft d nhftng cdu todn day<br />
dupe coi Id bo ngft dao chft khdng dupc coi \i<br />
chii ngft Id vi chiing khdng ddp ftng dupc tiSu<br />
chi ciia chu ngft (dupc xdc d|nh bdng thd ph^<br />
nguydn nhdn hda [5,151]).<br />
3.1. Theo chiing tdi, neu phdn tich theo cdch<br />
thft hai sd gfp nhung dilm vudng mic rit kh6<br />
lufn gidi mpt cdch thod ddng. Cy thi;<br />
<br />
s l 5 (247)-2016<br />
<br />
NG6N NGC & Ddi S6NG<br />
<br />
1) N I U coi ddy la nhftng cdu hay ciu tnic<br />
khdng chu ngft vdi vj ngft Id ngogi dfng tft<br />
(dfng tft ngogi hudng) vd b l ngft dupc ddo Idn<br />
phfa trudc thi phdi thiia nhan rdng chung Id<br />
nhftng cdu hay ciu trfte khdng trpn vpn (khdng<br />
day dft) vdi chft ngft bj tinh lupc. Tuy nhidn,<br />
cdch li gidi ndy vip phdi nhiing trd nggi sau:<br />
a) Trdn thuc tl, nhiing cdu hay ciu tiiie trdn<br />
ddy khdng tao in tupng ro rft v l sy tinh lupc<br />
(chft ngft) ma nhin chung, van dupc edm nhfn<br />
nhu nhiing cdu hay ciu tnic trpn v?n vl dl hilu<br />
diing nghTa ciia chiing, hiu nhu khdng cin dya<br />
vao ngft canh dl xdc djnh, khdi phyc Igi cdc tft<br />
bj cho Id lupc bd.<br />
b) Trong nhieu tnrdng hpp, rit khd xdc djnh<br />
chinh xdc cdc tft ngft dupc coi la chii ngft bj<br />
lupc bd dua vdo ngft cdnh; han niia, ngay cd<br />
khi dodn dupc chft till thye t l ciia hogt dfng<br />
ndu d vj ngft, vifc khdi phuc Igi chft ngft (bi coi<br />
Id Iuac bd) ciing khdng de dang vi dieu dd cd<br />
thi cho ta nhftng edu hay ciu trfte khdng ty<br />
nhidn, blnhthirdng.Sa sdnh:<br />
3a) Nd ldm bang lodi hgc. —* 3b) Nd, ngudi ta<br />
(ho?) ldm bdng lodi bgc. (?)<br />
2a) Luc mdm cam bung len, toi dgp thuc bgn<br />
toi dgy. -* 2b) Liic mdm cam chii nhd (?) bung<br />
len, toi dgp thOc bgn toi ddy. (?)<br />
Ngodi ra, trong trudng hpp chft the thyc te<br />
cda hogt ddng ndu d vj ngft da dupc bieu thj<br />
ttong cdu b£d tft gift vai trd trgng ngft (d cdu 4a)<br />
till vifc khoi phyc Igi chii ngft Id dieu hodn todn<br />
khdng till thyc hifn dupc. Chdng hgn, khdng<br />
the ndi: (4b) Chita ngudi ta x^ edch ddy<br />
khoang 1600 ndm bdi mdt nhd suAn Bd.<br />
2) Vifc coi nhftng cdu hay cau tnic tren ddy<br />
Id nhiing cau hay ciu tnic vdi bo ngft ddo ciing<br />
cd nhihig diem vudng mdc khdc. Cy thi:<br />
a) Nhu da biet bo ngft dao, nhin chung, deu<br />
cd the chuyen xuIng vj tri vln ed d sau dfng tft<br />
ma khdng dan den sy thay dii co bdn ciu tnic<br />
va -^ nghTa von cd cua cdu. So sdnh:<br />
(7a) Ldng tdi dfch chiim rdi. (Nam Cao)-><br />
(7b) Djch chiim long tdi rdi.<br />
(8a) Sdch ndy khdng nen dgc.->(8b) Khdng<br />
nin dgc sdch ndy.<br />
b) Trong nhftng cdu hay ciu trdc dang xem<br />
xet trdn ddy, vifc chuyln cdc tft dupc coi Id bl<br />
<br />
31<br />
<br />
ngft dao xuIng sau dfng tft - vj ngft se din den<br />
sy thay dii manh tinh chit cii phdp efta cdu, cy<br />
till, sd biln nhihig cdu (hay cau tiftc) dupe edm<br />
nhgn nhu cdu (ciu trfte) trpn ven thdnh cdu (cau<br />
triic) khdng trpn v^n. So sdnh:<br />
(2a) Lik mdm cam hung len, tdi ddp thOc bgn<br />
tdi dgy. —* (2c) Luc bung mdm cam len, tdi dgp<br />
thuc bgn tdi ddy.<br />
(3a) Nd 1 ^ bang lodi bgc. -•(3c) Ldm no<br />
bdng lodi bgc.<br />
(4a) CMia xdy td thdi cdch day hhodng mgt<br />
nghin sdu trdm ndm bdi mgt nhd su An Dg. —*<br />
(4c) Xdy chiia tu thdi cdch ddy khoang mgt<br />
nghin sdu trdm ndm bdi mgt nhd suAn Bg.<br />
Nhu cdc vi du cho Ihiy, vifc chuyln dii trat<br />
ty tft da tgo ra nhiing cdu hay ciu tnic rd rdng Id<br />
khdng trpn vpn. Hon niia, sy thay dii trgt ty tft<br />
nhu d cdu (2c) cdn dan din sy thay dii quan<br />
trpng cd vl nghTa (d edu ndy, hogt dfng bung<br />
lin cd till hilu la hogt dpng cua ^^tdr chft<br />
khdng phdi Id ciia chu nhd, hay nhdn vft nao<br />
dd). O cdu (4c), sy thay dii trat ty tft din din sy<br />
khdng phft hpp hay khdng rd rang cua mli quan<br />
hf ngft nghTa giiia dfng tft xqv vd cym danh tft<br />
mgt nhd su An Bg (cd the hieu chu ngft cua<br />
dfng tii xdy (bj tinh lupc) chi mpt n^udi khac<br />
chft khdng phdi chinh Id mdi nhd suAn Bg).<br />
3.2. Trdn ca sd sy phan tich tren, trong bai<br />
vilt ndy, chiing tdi nghidng vl cdch phan tinh<br />
thft nhat; theo dd, nhung cdu hay ciu tnic tren<br />
day dupc coi la nhiing cdu hay ciu true cd md<br />
hinh CN - VN. Tuy nhien, khac vdi quan niem<br />
dd dl cap d cdch phdn tich thft nhit, chiing tdi<br />
cho ring y nghTa bi dfng d day, vl thyc chat<br />
vln gin vdi -y nghia ciia dfng tft - vj ngft. Ngodi<br />
ra, can phan bift kilu cdu bj dfng cd dgng N -V<br />
nhu tren ddy vdi nhiing cdu cung cd dang N - V<br />
trong do cd sy tinh lupc chu ngft va bo ngft<br />
dupc ddo Idn trudc vj ngft. Dudi ddy chdng tdi<br />
se xin lugn giai lam rd van de nay.<br />
Net ddng chu y trong nhiing cau trdn day Id<br />
ve nghia, chiing khdng midu ta hanh dpng efta<br />
chii till hudng vdo dii thi md chii yeu bilu thi<br />
trgng thdi bj dfng ciia sy vgt do cae danh tft<br />
dftng trudc dfng tft bilu thi. Ndi each khac,<br />
nhihig cdu hay ciu trdc kilu ttdn ddy thye chit<br />
la cdu hay cau tnic bj dfng trong dd cdc tft bf<br />
<br />